Joint Written Project: Scoring Rubric

Joint Written Project:

Joint Written Project Scoring Rubric

80% on this rubric is passing - pass or fail grade is given - each team member receives same grade.

GENERAL:Assignment requires 10 PPt content Slides with Notes (dealing with important, meaty material; NOT title/agenda slides) & paper of reasonable length. Project Plan due within 5 calendar days after Assignment is provided. Students may ask the assigner for general feedback by email/phone and may submit a draft presentation to assigner for general feedback. Final presentation and paper must be submitted for grading within 30 calendar days after Project Plan is approved.

Print this Rubric

Paper - 60% of total score 0-1 2-4 5-7 8-9 10
Content and structure Paper is without any real content or structure Paper has minimal or superficial content and/or a poor structure Paper has adequate content and/or structure Paper has good content and/or structure Paper has excellent content and/or structure
Language Paper has many spelling and/or grammar errors Paper has some spelling and/or grammar errors Spelling is clean and adequate use of language Spelling is clean and good use of language Spelling is clean and excellent use of language
Referencing Paper has no references Paper has minimal and/or faulty references References are used where necessary References are used where necessary and refer to original work Excellent use of high-quality references
Knowledge and Wisdom Domain knowledge represented by the paper could be found from Internet sources in fifteen minutes or less Domain knowledge represented by the paper could easily found using common search engines Domain knowledge represented by the paper is a fairly complete coverage of the subject and brings the information together in a single paper that reflects the body of searchable knowledge available on the Internet after it is posted. Domain knowledge could only be found by hours of Internet searching as well as using books, periodicals and other sources, and represents an increase in the body of searchable knowledge available on the Internet after it is posted. Domain knowledge could only be found by hours of Internet searching, primary research such as interviews and experiments, as well as using books, periodicals and other sources, and represents an increase in the body of searchable knowledge available on the Internet after it is posted.
Community Service If published, the paper would do the community a disservice. The paper does not provide benefits to the community The paper provides some benefits to the community The paper benefits the community The paper benefits the community greatly
Project Plan 20% of total score 0-1 2-4 5-7 8-9 10
Schedule Schedule for planning, organizing, staffing, leading or directing the tasks is non-existant Schedule for planning, organizing, staffing, leading or directing the tasks is minimal. Schedule provides sufficient steps for planning, organizing, staffing, leading or directing, and controlling the project. Schedule provides complete steps for planning, organizing, staffing, leading or directing, and controlling the project. Schedule provides comprehensive steps for planning, organizing, staffing, leading or directing, and controlling the project.
Critical Path No mention in plan of dependencies Dependencies may be present, but order of steps appears to be random. Dependencies are sufficiently evident, order of steps is well thought out. Dependencies are clearly evident, well thought out. Dependencies are clearly evident, well thought out, back up plans ready when appropriate.
Presentation 20% of total score 0-1 2-4 5-7 8-9 10
Presentation does not summarize paper, does not focus on crucial points, is not written at a management level Presentation summarizes paper, highlights some crucial points, is written at a management level Presentation summarizes paper, highlights most crucial points, is formatted well enough to convey the information, is written at a management level Presentation summarizes paper, highlights all crucial points, is formatted well for rapid comprehension, is written at a management level Presentation fully summarizes paper, highlights crucial points, is formatted well for rapid comprehension, is written at a CIO management level
REFLECTIONS - Before JWP grade will be entered for a student, the student must provide Reflections within 1 week after the JWP is completed. Student will submit to info@sans.edu a written document not to exceed 2 typed pages (single spaced, double spaced between paragraphs) reflecting on student's own performance and student's use of leadership skills, and on the partner's performance and the partner's use of leadership skills. (Refer to leadership essay).